Problem 99 — Visual explainer (undergrad) ========================================= Problem statement --------------- Let $A\subseteq\mathbb{R}^2$ be a set of $n$ points with minimum distance equal to 1, chosen to minimise the diameter of $A$. If $n$ is sufficiently large then must there be three points in $A$ which form an equilateral triangle of size 1? Picture ------- Plane picture: y ^ | o o | o | o +-----------------> x Question: what to look at ------------------------ - Restate the problem as: given the constraint, what asymptotic bound or structure must follow? - Use the comments as benchmarks (best known bounds / constructions). Context ------- Area hint: incidence geometry / combinatorial geometry. Benchmarks / known results (from comments) ---------------------------------------- - Thue proved that the minimal such diameter is achieved (asymptotically) by the points in a triangular lattice intersected with a circle. - In general Erd\H{o}s believed such a set must have very large intersection with the triangular lattice (perhaps as many as $(1-o(1))n$). - Simonovits doubted the truth of this conjecture.' In he offers \$100 for a counterexample but only \$50 for a proof. - The stated problem is false for $n=4$, for example taking the points to be vertices of a square.